Wednesday, October 21, 2009
E Readers
So, Barnes & Noble officially launched its Nook e-reader yesterday. The Nook is available for pre-order and will begin to ship on November 30. Sony has a couple of E-Readers as well. And, of course, there's the Kindle.
I tried the Kindle (Kindle 1). I wasn't a fan. Here were my three biggest complaints, and I'm not sure whether these complaints are specific to the Kindle 1 or are applicable to all e-readers as I haven't tried any others.
1. I often have a bite-sized window to read a chapter or a portion of a chapter of a book. I like to sit down, page through my book and see, "Can I get to the end of the chapter? Is there a good place to stop if I cannot?" I couldn't do that with the Kindle. Screens obviously don't load anywhere near as quickly as you can flip them in a physical book.
2. I have no conception of "pages" on the Kindle 1. Even if I could easily figure out how many "screens" there are until the end of a chapter, I have no conception of what that means. I have around 35 years of reading experience and have come to understand the concept of, "Honey, I'll turn off the light soon--I have five pages until the end of the chapter." I know, based on the book, how long that's going to take. "Honey, I'll turn off the light soon--let me see--counting screens--still counting [See 1 above]--OK, I have 22 screens" just isn't helpful.
3. I like paging back. Sometimes, I want to remember a character's name or a reference from earlier in a book. I can generally picture in my mind approximately where in the book I need to look and where the reference appeared on a page. On the Kindle 1, I could bookmark a page, but usually I don't know that I am going to want to go back there until much later. And, as the Daniel Suarez Virtual Book Club book is Anathem, complete with a glossary beginning on page 890, it's nice to be able to easily flip to and fro without having to press a bunch of numbers.
My other problem with e-readers in general is that I cannot figure out what books, magazines and newspapers I can get on what e-readers. Each manufacturer says something different about what's available. I am assuming (though do not know for sure) that items like best selling books are available on all e-readers.
If anyone can enlighten me here, please comment. I have met many Kindle lovers who have few, if any, complaints--all of which are outweighed by the convenience of the Kindle.
Remember, Reading is Fundamental. I know that because that's what they used to say on Saturday mornings.
I tried the Kindle (Kindle 1). I wasn't a fan. Here were my three biggest complaints, and I'm not sure whether these complaints are specific to the Kindle 1 or are applicable to all e-readers as I haven't tried any others.
1. I often have a bite-sized window to read a chapter or a portion of a chapter of a book. I like to sit down, page through my book and see, "Can I get to the end of the chapter? Is there a good place to stop if I cannot?" I couldn't do that with the Kindle. Screens obviously don't load anywhere near as quickly as you can flip them in a physical book.
2. I have no conception of "pages" on the Kindle 1. Even if I could easily figure out how many "screens" there are until the end of a chapter, I have no conception of what that means. I have around 35 years of reading experience and have come to understand the concept of, "Honey, I'll turn off the light soon--I have five pages until the end of the chapter." I know, based on the book, how long that's going to take. "Honey, I'll turn off the light soon--let me see--counting screens--still counting [See 1 above]--OK, I have 22 screens" just isn't helpful.
3. I like paging back. Sometimes, I want to remember a character's name or a reference from earlier in a book. I can generally picture in my mind approximately where in the book I need to look and where the reference appeared on a page. On the Kindle 1, I could bookmark a page, but usually I don't know that I am going to want to go back there until much later. And, as the Daniel Suarez Virtual Book Club book is Anathem, complete with a glossary beginning on page 890, it's nice to be able to easily flip to and fro without having to press a bunch of numbers.
My other problem with e-readers in general is that I cannot figure out what books, magazines and newspapers I can get on what e-readers. Each manufacturer says something different about what's available. I am assuming (though do not know for sure) that items like best selling books are available on all e-readers.
If anyone can enlighten me here, please comment. I have met many Kindle lovers who have few, if any, complaints--all of which are outweighed by the convenience of the Kindle.
Remember, Reading is Fundamental. I know that because that's what they used to say on Saturday mornings.
Subscribe to:
Post Comments (Atom)
hi mark. what the helk is RIF? best, your SISTER
ReplyDeleteReading is Fundamental
ReplyDeleteI know that because they used to tell me that every Saturday morning between cartoons.